Matthew 16:13-20
August 27, 2017
A man dies and arrives at the pearly gates where he sees St. Peter…
And I don’t know the punchline of the joke…
I actually googled “best pearly gates jokes” and they just weren’t very funny.
Some were sexist;
And some were about lawyers – which seemed unkind.
But all those ‘pearly gates’ jokes we’ve heard over the years
Stem from this passage in the gospel of Matthew
Where Jesus passes on the keys to the kingdom.
Today’s story begins as Jesus and his disciples are walking in the region of Caesarea Philippi.
It’s important to know something about this place.
Caesarea Philippi was the hub of Roman power and wealth.
It was a trading port and people came with money to spend.
Rome had started massive building projects there at the time of Jesus.
It wasn’t only a place where money and power were worshipped…
Other gods were worshipped there as well.
There were shrines to the god Ba’al and the god Pan.
Jesus goes to a place where rabbis say no good Jew would go.
And as he’s walking around he asks his disciples,
“who do people say that I am?”
They answer that some say, “John the Baptist.”
John the Baptist had been recently beheaded…
Jesus was his cousin – and perhaps they looked alike.
Others said that Jesus was Elijah.
Scripture said that the messiah would come after Elijah returned –
So perhaps Jesus was Elijah.
Still other said that Jesus was Jeremiah or one of the prophets.
He certainly sounded like a prophet –
Proclaiming words of warning and words of hope from God to the people.
But then Jesus turns directly to the disciples and asks them,
“But who do you say that I am?”
“Why are you following me?”
(And perhaps that’s a question for us to consider this week as well –
Why do we follow Jesus?)
Simon Peter answers,
“You are the messiah;
The son of the living God.”
All the names the people were giving were dead –
Jesus is the son of a God who is alive!
And then Jesus turns and blesses Simon.
He says, “Blessed are you Simon, son of Jonah….”
You are Peter
(The Greek word for ‘rock’ is ‘petra’ – so it’s a play on words.)
“And on this rock I will build my church;
And the gates of Hades will not prevail against it.”
On this rock I will build my church;
And the gates of Hades will not prevail against it.
Over the years there have been many interpretations what Jesus meant by this.
Roman Catholics generally believe that Jesus was talking directly to Peter…
And so when he said “on this rock,” he meant “on Peter I will build my church.”
This is why Peter is at the pearly gates in those jokes – and not Andrew or Bartholomew or Peter.
And it’s why the RC understanding is that the pope is the descendent of Peter,
The foundation of the church.
Protestants on the other hand generally have the understanding that
When Jesus said, “On this rock I will build my church,”
He meant not Peter the person, but Peter’s confession:
“You are the messiah, the son of the living God,”
And that the church is built on Jesus as the son of the living God.
I’d like to introduce a third possibility for today..
And it has to do with the location of where this story takes place – in Casarea Philiipi.
Just outside of Ceasarea Phillipi there is a shrine to the god Pan.
It’s at the opening to a large cave.
And through the cave a tributary to the Jordan River passed through.
In Jesus’ day the opening to this cave was thought to be the opening to the underworld –
The opening to the power of evil.
And it was called, the “Gates of Hades.”
So perhaps, when Jesus said,
“On this rock I will build my church,
And the Gates of Hades shall not prevail upon it,”
He meant that his church was built here… at the Gates of Hades..
To directly confront the forces of evil, the forces of death, the forces of the underworld.
That the church wasn’t called to be away from the source of evil,
But directly in front of it.
Some of you probably saw an article in yesterday’s Washington Post.
It was an interview with Pastor William Lamar of Metropolitan AME church in DC.
The reporter said that in the 50’s and 60’s the church was at the forefront
Of the movement for civil rights.
But that seemed not to be the case anymore – the reporter asked Rev. Lamar why that was.
Pastor Lamar said that the church is called to confront evil and hatred and racism and bigotry.
It is still called to be at the forefront of the fight for civil rights…
And when it is not – it is committing “theological malpractice.”
Theological malpractice.
Tomorrow is the anniversary of the March on Washington.
There is a 1000 Ministers March walking from the MLK memorial to the DOJ.
(the Lutheran contingent is meeting up ahead of time – let me know if you’d like to meet us there.)
I suppose that Washington, DC isn’t much different from Caesarea Philippi –
A place that worships power and wealth.
Tomorrow we are committing ourselves to be a church that confronts evil;
A church built on this rock that will not be silent;
A church built in front of the Gates of Hades –
And the Gates of Hades will not prevail.
So I have a new pearly gates joke that isn’t really funny…
It goes like this:
A man, or a woman, or a group of people find themselves at the Gates of Hades;
And they meet at those gates not just St. Peter, but the entire church.
The church that was built to be in that spot.
And the church stands together and says,
“We’re locking the door.
There is no room for hate here.”
Amen.